Over the years we have seen many providers boast about their 100% success rates and HMRC approved processes however, in truth, R&D is no different to other areas of taxation. There is always the possibility of a HMRC enquiry.
With error and fraud in R&D costing the taxpayer an estimated £1.13 billion, HMRC have started taking action with more compliance checks being carried out.
There isn't a set list of red flags that prompt an enquiry however, there are some common trends.
#1 Claims originating from sectors with traditionally lower R&D intensity: This situation can raise suspicion and prompt HMRC to investigate further.
#2 SMEs in receipt of funding: HMRC frequently encounters errors in this specific area which has led to additional scrutiny.
#3 Substantially high claim value: If your claim value is significantly higher than the average tax savings or exceeds previous R&D claims by a large margin this could prompt an enquiry.
While certain enquiries may be targeted based on risk or sectors, others can be completely random. As a result, it is impossible to entirely avoid an enquiry. However, you can take steps to minimise the associated risks by ensuring your claim provides HMRC with all the details needed to carry out a proper assessment.
How to Be Prepared for an HMRC Enquiry
Tip 1 - Maintain Detailed Documentation:
One of the most critical aspects of preparing for an HMRC enquiry is maintaining comprehensive and accurate documentation. Keep detailed records of all R&D activities, including project plans, technical specifications, research notes, and financial documentation. This documentation will help support your claims and demonstrate the eligibility of your R&D projects.
Tip 2 - Understand the R&D Guidelines:
Familiarise yourself with the guidelines provided by HMRC for R&D claims. Ensure that you have a thorough understanding of the eligibility criteria, qualifying expenditure, and documentation requirements. Staying up-to-date with these guidelines will enable you to make informed decisions and avoid potential pitfalls.
Tip 3 - Maintain Strong Communication Channels:
Maintaining open and transparent communication channels with HMRC is crucial. If you have any uncertainties or questions regarding R&D claims, seek clarification from HMRC directly. Proactively engaging with HMRC demonstrates your commitment to compliance.
Tip 4 - Respond in a timely manner:
It may seem like an obvious step but you would be surprised how many companies miss the response deadlines. Maintaining compliance is crucial for fostering a strong relationship with HMRC. If you require additional time to respond, it is important to request an extension from HMRC and keep them informed throughout the process.
Tip 5 - Engage R&D Tax Specialists:
Consider engaging the services of experienced R&D tax consultants. These professionals have in-depth knowledge of R&D tax incentives and can assist you in preparing your claims. They can also help ensure that your claims align with HMRC requirements, reducing the likelihood of triggering an enquiry.